Direct or Indirect Surgical Approach of Zygomatic Complex Fracture: A Comparative Study

Abstract

Zygoma is considered the main support of the midface. Zygoma is frequently fractured owing to its prominent site on the face. Treatment of zygomaticomaxillary complex fractures can be performed through either conservative or surgical measures (closed or open reduction). The study was a cross-sectional retrospective observational investigation done at 4 hospitals in Ramadi and Baghdad cities, Iraq. This investigation covered a duration of 6 years (2016–2021). We reviewed the medical records of patients with ZCFs. The participants were divided into 2 groups according to the approach used for their management (direct versus indirect approach). Data regarding the demographic and clinical characteristics were recorded for each subject. Of 265 patients with ZCFs, 209 (78.9%) were males. The highest age group affected was 18 to 40 years (51.7%). The majority of the ZCFs were caused by road traffic accidents (31.7%). Most of the cases belong to single fractures (72.1%). Cheek flattening (73.6%) was the commonest sign of the ZCFs. The majority of the fractures were treated by direct approach, 65.4% of the isolated fractures and 62.2% for multiple fractures. Excellent patient satisfaction was seen in the majority of the cases. There were no statistically significant differences between the 2 approaches regarding the abovementioned variables (P-value > 0.05). The majority of the cases were with excellent patient satisfaction (n = 149) while only 7 patients with poor satisfaction. The age groups below 18 years and 18 to 40 years were associated with excellent patient satisfaction than good and poor satisfaction. All (n = 7) of the cases with poor satisfaction belong to the age group above 40 years. The majority of male (n = 113) and female (n = 36) patients were with excellent satisfaction, while all patients with poor results were males (n = 7). There were statistically significant differences between the results of the patient satisfaction and age group and complications (P-value < 0.05). The ophthalmic complications were the most complications seen after ZCF surgical treatment (2.56%). Direct and indirect approaches can be used safely in the treatment of ZCFs owing to excellent patient satisfaction in the majority of the cases and a low complication rate. This study aims to evaluate the demographic and clinical characteristics and to compare different surgical procedures to treat patients with zygomaticomaxillary complex fractures in a country overwhelmed by violence.