Exploring Perspectives on Agroecological Transition in Scotland with Critical Systems Heuristics

Abstract

Abstract Critical systems heuristics (CSH) is a framework that facilitates reflective practice in exploring and solving complex management problems. Despite its versatility, CSH has so far been under-utilised in addressing problems concerning the environment and sustainability. We apply CSH to explore perspectives on agroecological transition in Scotland. In interviews with 10 farmers, agricultural professionals, and researchers, we demonstrate the utility of boundary critique as a practice for unpacking the judgements that underpin perspectives on Scottish farming. Moreover, we derive a series of practical insights and recommendations to progress agroecological transition in Scotland, including: support for a greater diversity of farming systems; action across the entire food system to avoid ‘lock-ins’; improved tools to measure farming outcomes; and nuanced and precise conversations regarding the nature and purpose of agroecological farming. In doing so, we demonstrate that in the context of sustainable transitions, CSH need not be limited to a retrospective analytical framework, but may guide reflective practice throughout the entire research process.