Experience of Research Ethics Committees in Africa during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Abstract

Abstract Background and objective : Globally, COVID-19 has caused a number of challenges including the functioning of research ethics committees (RECs) with the impact being expected to be more pronounced in resource-limited countries. The objective of this study was to describe RECs' functions and challenges experienced during the pandemic in Africa. Method A cross-sectional study covering Anglophone and Francophone countries in Africa was done. Data was collected using an online Google form questionnaire. The link to the form was sent to REC chairs and secretaries to fill in online. Descriptive data analysis was done using Microsoft Excel and SPSS version 25. Result A total of 98 study participants (50 members and 48 chairs) responded from 16 African countries. The mean (standard deviation) age of REC members was 47 (12) and over half of them, 27 (54%) were female. Most REC members and chairs were physicians, while 48% of RECs were affiliated with academic institutes. Ninety percent of REC chairs reported that their REC was accredited; however, only three had recognition by Strategic Initiative for Developing Capacity in Ethics Review (SIDCER). RECs reported reviewing COVID-19 related protocols. In 2019, chairs reported RECs reviewing 5,860 protocols with a 13% increment in 2020. During the COVID-19 pandemic, there was an increment in protocol amendment (79%), deviation (29%), and early protocol termination (25%). Most (96%) RECs followed COVID-19 prevention institutional policies including limiting face-to-face meetings and shifting to virtual platforms. RECs challenges in reviewing COVID-19 related proposals were issues related to risk/benefit, scientific design, and informed consent. Conclusion The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted the functions of RECs in Africa, both in the increase in the volume of proposals for review and presenting new ethical challenges including in risk-benefit analysis. There is a need to strengthen RECs in the region through different mechanisms, by building their capacity through initiatives like the SIDCER recognition program. To strengthen African RECs in a sustainable manner, some of the interventions could be establishing National and regional REC databases, and putting in place continuous training opportunities preferably through an online platform.