Affiliation:
1. Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine
2. Shanghai University of Medicine & Health Sciences
3. Xinhua Hospital,Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine,Shanghai
Abstract
Abstract
Background
In the process of clinical diagnosis and treatment, doctors' decision-making ability is closely related to patients' life, and moral orientation is one of the most important factors affecting clinical decision-making. So this study aims to understand the proclivity of choice by medical students and illustrating the awareness status and features when faced with difficult positions.
Methods
Develop an electronic questionnaire based on the ethical dilemma cases by Professor Sandel, and then distribute the questionnaires via sojump to the students in Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine in order to investigate their moral orientation.
Results
The results show that among the trolley dilemma, the scenes in which medical students agree to sacrifice one to save another five in turns are the switch(47.6%), the side track(for a child)(38.0%) and the footbridge scene (8.5%). Postgraduates incline utilitarianism more than undergraduate students in switch and side track(for a child) (P < 0.05), and there are no statistical significances in gender and majors (P > 0.05). While in the emergency doctor case, most students prefer to utilitarianism regardless of whether the critical patient chooses to die voluntarily or not. On the contrary, students tend to choose denotology in organ transplantation case no matter the healthy man is willing to donate his organs or not. And when patient with advanced cancer voluntarily donates organs, female students and postgraduates are more inclined to the utilitarian principle than male students and undergraduates(P < 0.05). There are no statistical significances between majors in emergency doctor and organ transplantation.
Conclusions
This study suggests that medical students are reluctant to sacrifice one to save the other five, and the specific environment in clinical practice has a great impact on medical students. At the same time, this study suggests that medical ethics education still has shortcomings, which can be further strengthened.
Publisher
Research Square Platform LLC
Reference30 articles.
1. The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of the Double Effect;Foot P;Oxf Rev,1967
2. Interpersonal relationship mindsets and rejection sensitivity across cultures: The role of relational mobility;Lou NM;Pers Indiv Differ,2017
3. How) Do You Regret Killing One to Save Five? Affective and Cognitive Regret Differ After Utilitarian and Deontological Decisions;Goldstein-Greenwood J;Pers Soc Psychol Bull,2020
4. Effect of Psilocybin on Empathy and Moral Decision-Making;Pokorny T;Int J Neuropsychopharmacol,2017
5. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation;Bentham J;American Political Science Association,1962