Stigma relating to tuberculosis infection prevention and control implementation in rural health facilities in South Africa – a theoretical analysis with opportunities for mitigation

Abstract

Abstract Background Tuberculosis (TB) is a stigmatised disease due to its associations with poverty, HIV, transmission risk and mortality. The use of visible TB infection prevention and control (IPC) measures, such as masks or isolation, can contribute to stigma. Methods To explore stigma in this condition, we conducted in-depth individual interviews with 18 health workers and 15 patients in the rural Eastern Cape of South Africa using a semi-structured interview guide and narrative approach. We used reflexive thematic analysis and applied Link and Phelan’s theoretical model of stigma. Results Participants shared poignant narratives of TB stigma, often entailing TB IPC, with some feeling ‘less than human’. We found TB IPC measures sometimes exacerbated stigma, for example through introducing physical isolation that became prolonged, or through a mask marking the person out as being ill with TB. In this context, stigma emerged from the narrow definition of what mask-wearing symbolises, in contrast with broader uses of masks as a preventative measure. In this way, the health facility itself was shown to play an important role in generating and perpetuating IPC related stigma. We applied ‘ubuntu’ as African humanist conceptual framework to develop recommendations of how TB IPC implementation could be destigmatised. Conclusion Health facilities may unwittingly perpetuate stigma, but they also have the potential to reduce it. Ubuntu emphases shared humanity and collective wellbeing and could engage with some of the deep-rooted contributors to TB stigma. An ubuntu-informed approach could underpin a local policy change to universal masking, thereby destigmatising an important IPC practice.