Axial twisting within an ending loop of a continuous suture pattern effects the biomechanical properties of knots of certain suture sizes and types

Abstract

Abstract OBJECTIVE To determine whether axial twisting within an ending loop negatively impacts maximum load to failure and failure mode of suture knots. SAMPLES 525 knots (15 samples each of 7 different suture types/sizes tested in 5 knot-twist configurations each). PROCEDURES Each suture type (polydioxanone [PDO], Monoderm [polyglecaprone 25], and Nylon) and size (1, 0, 2-0, 3-0) were used to create a starting square knot, and each of the following ending square knot configurations: 0 twists, 1 twist, 4 twists, and 10 twists. Each suture was tested for failure using a universal testing machine (Instron, Instron Corp) with a 100 kg load cell at a speed of 100 mm/min. Each suture and knot was evaluated for a mode of failure using gross evaluation of the knots and video footage recorded during testing. Maximum load at failure (P-value set at .005) and failure mode (p-value set at 0.003) were recorded for each group. RESULTS Maximum load at failure was decreased in knots tied within ending loops containing more twists for some types and sizes of the suture. With 4 twists, 0-PDO, 1 PDO, and 2-0 Nylon was more likely to fail at the knot than knots with 0 twists. All sutures containing 10 twists, except 3-0 Monoderm, were more likely to fail at the knot than knots with 0 twists. CLINICAL RELEVANCE The number of twists within the ending loop may not increase the risk of failure at the knot; however, it can decrease the maximum load to failure at a knot, particularly as the suture size increases.