Identification of seasonal varves in the lower Pliocene Bouse Formation, lower Colorado River Valley, and implications for Colorado Plateau uplift

Abstract

Abstract The cause of Cenozoic uplift of the Colorado Plateau is one of the largest remaining problems of Cordilleran tectonics. Difficulty in discriminating between two major classes of uplift mechanisms, one related to lithosphere modification by low-angle subduction and the other related to active mantle processes following termination of subduction, is hampered by lack of evidence for the timing of uplift. The carbonate member of the Pliocene Bouse Formation in the lower Colorado River Valley southwest of the Colorado Plateau has been interpreted as estuarine, in which case its modern elevation of up to 330 m above sea level would be important evidence for late Cenozoic uplift. The carbonate member includes laminated marl and claystone interpreted previously in at least one locality as tidal, which is therefore of marine origin. We analyzed lamination mineralogy, oxygen and carbon isotopes, and thickness variations to discriminate between a tidal versus seasonal origin. Oxygen and carbon isotopic analysis of two laminated carbonate samples shows an alternating pattern of lower δ18O and δ13C associated with micrite and slightly higher δ18O and δ13C associated with siltstone, which is consistent with seasonal variation. Covariation of alternating δ18O and δ13C also indicates that post-depositional chemical alteration did not affect these samples. Furthermore, we did not identify any periodic thickness variations suggestive of tidal influence. We conclude that lamination characteristics indicate seasonal genesis in a lake rather than tidal genesis in an estuary and that the laminated Bouse Formation strata provide no constraints on the timing of Colorado Plateau uplift.