Affiliation:
1. University of Hertfordshire, UK
Abstract
Criminologists have often highlighted how the news media tends to disseminate simplified and stigmatised narratives to represent violence against women. Furthermore, these narratives often interweave with class-based fears, sensationalism, and mythology. However, recently, several authors have begun to examine the potential of new media sources (podcasts, documentary series, social media) to subvert these narratives. Drawing on a case study examining the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier in West Cork, Ireland (December 1996), the current chapter examines the ways in which three recent new media examinations of the case subvert and reinforce these narratives. The chapter demonstrates that while the new media sources foreground the victim's biography and background, give voice to her family, and situate the case within broader social and political contexts, they also reinforce class-based stereotypes relating to deserving and undeserving victims and problematically focus on the mythical elements of the case for entertainment purposes.
Reference38 articles.
1. Bailey, E. (1997). Du Plantier maintains silence on his wife’s brutal murder. Irish Examiner. Available at: https://www.irishnewsarchive.com/free_search/?pub=IEX&search_olive=eoin%20bailey&yearFrom=1996&toYear=1997
2. The Impact of Gender-Based Family Roles on Criminal Sentencing
3. Black, L. (2009). The representation of female offenders in Irish newspapers [MA Thesis]. University College Dublin.
4. BongerW. (1916). Criminality and economic conditions (1st ed.). Creative Media Partners.
5. Brent, H. (2021). Ian Bailey told French prosecutors to ‘Pog mo Thoin’ when they demanded he face trial in France. Available at: https://www.irishpost.com/news/ian-bailey-told-french-prosecutors-to-pog-mo-thoin-when-they-demanded-he-face-trial-in-paris-215300