Abstract
This article deals with methodological challenges and presents solutions for the study of people who depart from state-subsidized housing in Ethiopia, Morocco, and South Africa. Having sold or rented out their units, these people have left and now live at dispersed locations. Assuming that many “missing people” leave state housing because of project-related shortcomings, studying the reasons for their departure is crucial to understanding standardized housing programs. “Missing people” urge scholars to emphasize the afterlives of housing policy interventions as a necessary analytical dimension. However, such research is confronted with three major methodological challenges: How is it possible to approach and study people who have disappeared from the area of a housing intervention? How can one link exploratory, in-depth qualitative accounts, rooted in subjective perceptions of the everyday, to potential structural deficiencies of standardized housing interventions? What kind of methodologies may help take into account the temporalities of displacement and resettlement? In order to overcome these challenges, the article presents innovative forms of purposive sampling and discusses analytical strategies, which—based on Clapham’s framework of “housing pathways”—bridge relational and structural perspectives to housing programs.
Reference58 articles.
1. Alem, G. (2021). Urban plans and conflicting interests in sustainable cross-boundary land governance, the case of national urban and regional plans in Ethiopia. Sustainability, 13(6), Article 3081.
2. Anand, N., & Rademacher, A. (2011). Housing in the urban age: Inequality and aspiration in Mumbai. Antipode, 43(5), 1748–1772.
3. Arrif, A. (1999). Les compétences citadins à l’épreuve de l’exclusion: L’exemple du bidonvilles de Ben M’Sik à Casablanca (Maroc) [The capacities of urban citizens challenged by exclusion: The example of shantytown Ben M’Sik in Casablanca (Morocco)]. In P. Signoles, G. El Kadi, & R. Sidi Boumedine (Eds.), Etudes de l’annuaire de l’Afrique du Nord. L’urbain dans le monde arabe: Politiques, instruments et acteurs [Yearbook North Africa. The urban in the Arab world: Politics, instruments, and actors] (pp. 297–317). CNRS Éditions.
4. Beier, R. (2019). From the city to the desert: Analysing shantytown resettlement in Casablanca, Morocco, from residents’ perspectives. Logos.
5. Beier, R. (2021). From visible informality to splintered informalities: Reflections on the production of “formality” in a Moroccan housing programme. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 45(6), 930–947.