Impact of respiratory motion on proton pencil beam scanning FLASH radiotherapy: an in silico and phantom measurement study

Abstract

AbstractObjective. To investigate the effects of respiratory motion on the delivered dose in the context of proton pencil beam scanning (PBS) transmission FLASH radiotherapy (FLASH-RT) by simulation and phantom measurements.Approach. An in-house simulation code was employed to performin silicosimulation of 2D dose distributions for clinically relevant proton PBS transmission FLASH-RT treatments. A moving simulation grid was introduced to investigate the impacts of various respiratory motion and treatment delivery parameters on the dynamic PBS dose delivery. A strip-ionization chamber array detector and an IROC motion platform were employed to perform phantom measurements of the 2D dose distribution for treatment fields similar to those used for simulation.Main results. Clinically relevant respiratory motion and treatment delivery parameters resulted in degradation of the delivered dose compared to the static delivery as translation and distortion. Simulation showed that the gamma passing rates (2 mm/2% criterion) and target coverage could drop below 50% and 80%, respectively, for certain scenarios if no mitigation strategy was used. The gamma passing rates and target coverage could be restored to more than 95% and 98%, respectively, for short beams delivered at the maximal inhalation or exhalation phase. The simulation results were qualitatively confirmed in phantom measurements with the motion platform.Significance. Respiratory motion could cause dose quality degradation in a clinically relevant proton PBS transmission FLASH-RT treatment if no mitigation strategy is employed, or if an adequate margin is not given to the target. Besides breath-hold, gated delivery can be an alternative motion management strategy to ensure high consistency of the delivered dose while maintaining minimal dose to the surrounding normal tissues. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study on motion impacts in the context of proton transmission FLASH radiotherapy.