Accessibility and use of novel methods for predicting physical activity and energy expenditure using accelerometry: a scoping review

Abstract

Abstract Use of raw acceleration data and/or ‘novel’ analytic approaches like machine learning for physical activity measurement will not be widely implemented if methods are not accessible to researchers. Objective: This scoping review characterizes the validation approach, accessibility and use of novel analytic techniques for classifying energy expenditure and/or physical activity intensity using raw or count-based accelerometer data. Approach: Three databases were searched for articles published between January 2000 and February 2021. Use of each method was coded from a list of citing articles compiled from Google Scholar. Authors’ provision of access to the model (e.g., by request, sample code) was recorded. Main Results: Studies (N = 168) included adults (n = 143), and/or children (n = 38). Model use ranged from 0 to 27 uses/year (average 0.83) with 101 models that have never been used. Approximately half of uses occurred in a free-living setting (52%) and/or by other authors (56%). Over half of included articles (n = 107) did not provide complete access to their model. Sixty-one articles provided access to their method by including equations, coefficients, cut-points, or decision trees in the paper (n = 48) and/or by providing access to code (n = 13). Significance: The proliferation of approaches for analyzing accelerometer data outpaces the use of these models in practice. As less than half of the developed models are made accessible, it is unsurprising that so many models are not used by other researchers. We encourage researchers to make their models available and accessible for better harmonization of methods and improved capabilities for device-based physical activity measurement.