Optimal characterisation of profile features

Abstract

Abstract Segmentation of profile features is mainly described in two standards: ISO 4287 for profile elements, used to calculate RSm and Rc, and ISO 12085 for profile motifs, used to calculate R&W parameters. These methods are commonly criticised for their unstability, although they provide valuable results when used in an adequate context [25]. A new profile segmentation based on watersheds is now introduced in ISO 21920-2 and ISO 16610-45, adapted from areal segmentation [ISO 25178-2, [22]. The areal feature parameters, chap. 3 in Characterisation of Areal Surface Texture, Leach Ed. Springer], with the hope to solve most of the existing problems. However, there are very few comparisons between these methods and almost no recommendations for the configuration of the watershed segmentation. This paper discusses the validity of applying segmentation methods on certain profiles and proposes a validity criterion. It then investigates algorithmic differences between the watershed segmentation and the classical Motifs method, compares the results between the two methods, and suggests guidelines and good practices to obtain significant correlations.