Author:
Nada Omar Hassan Ali,Győri Zsuzsanna
Abstract
Purpose
The aim of this study is to evaluate the adoption and quality of integrated reports in the European Union (EU).
Design/methodology/approach
The sample consists of 147 listed firms from the 18 EU countries during 2013–2020. This study creates a disclosure index – based on the balanced scorecard (BSC) that reflects the information content of integrated reports. The content analysis method is used to measure the integrated reporting quality (IRQ).
Findings
The findings demonstrate that the IRQ increased across the study’s time frame, going from 49.3% in 2013 to 77% in 2020. Furthermore, financial disclosures still get the most attention in the integrated reporting (IR), followed by learning and growth perspective disclosures. In addition, businesses in the financial and industrial sectors rely more on integrated reports. However, the utility sector has the highest IRQ score. By country, Spain has the highest rate of IR adoption, followed by France. Other countries, such as Austria and Hungary, have only implemented IR by one company each.
Research limitations/implications
This study adds to the IR literature a new approach to measure IRQ by linking BSC with the IR framework. Empirically, businesses of any size can use this method to assess the degree of balance between the revealed financial and nonfinancial information in their reports.
Practical implications
Empirically, this study helps IR practitioners in determining how widely IR is used in Europe and in updating the database on the IR website. It helps them update and improve the IR framework by identifying the elements that have the least transparency and quality, investigating the causes and enhancing them.
Originality/value
To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this study is the first to examine the IRQ in EU countries by linking the BSC with IR elements. This is to split the elements into their own pillars, making it easier to track disclosure and evaluate the corporations’ interest in revealing these perspectives, on their own and collectively.
Subject
Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous),Accounting,Management Information Systems
Reference84 articles.
1. Compliance of integrated reporting disclosures with the international framework of integrated reporting – analysis of quoted public banking companies in Sri Lanka;The International Journal of Business and Management,2016
2. Quantity versus quality: the value relevance of CSR disclosure of Saudi companies;Corporate Ownership and Control,2016
3. Integrated capital reporting and companies' sustainable value: evidence from the Asian continent;Asian Review of Accounting,2020
4. The economic consequences associated with integrated report quality: capital market and real effects;Accounting, Organizations and Society,2017
5. In pursuit of a ‘single source of truth’: from threatened legitimacy to integrated reporting;Journal of Business Ethics,2017