Author:
Kang Ju Hui,Ko Eun-Young,Choi Gi Woong
Abstract
Purpose
This study aims to explore scientific discourses on vaccination in YouTube comments using the Connectivism theory as a foundational guide in the inquiry of understanding knowledge seeking and sharing. The authors sought to understand how individuals share and seek information by using external sources through URL links to validate their arguments.
Design/methodology/approach
Using content analysis, the authors extracted and analysed 584 random comments with URL links from eight YouTube videos scientifically addressing the purpose of vaccines. The comments were coded by stance (pro, anti, and neutral) and the type of resource to observe how their links were used.
Findings
The results showed that URL links were composed of quotes, questions, and opinions. Many sources came from research papers, conspiracy websites, or other videos. Some of the comments did not accurately reflect the information from research papers and showed little scientific reasoning. This suggests the need for critical evaluation among individuals when finding information online.
Research limitations/implications
The findings can be expanded to explore different types of information literacy practices in the comment section of social media for both informal and formal environments.
Practical implications
YouTube is useful in fostering scientific discourse and information-seeking/sharing practices among individuals. However, considering the inaccuracy of content deliverance, educators and individuals will need to consider how to teach/conduct information literacy skills when implementing social media for educational purposes.
Originality/value
Only a few studies have conducted research on comments using URL links, the originality of sources and how the sources were used in argumentation.
Reference66 articles.
1. Social media for knowledge-sharing: a systematic literature review;Telematics and Informatics,2019
2. Learning from YouTube: an analysis of information literacy in user discourse,2011
3. Auxier, B. and Anderson, M. (2022), “Social media use in 2021”, Pew Research Center: Internet, Science and Tech, available at: www.pewresearch.org/internet/2021/04/07/social-media-use-in-2021/ (accessed 12 January 2022).
4. Mumps outbreak in orthodox Jewish communities in the United States;New England Journal of Medicine,2012
5. Health information seeking behavior among college students;Journal of Community Health,2018