COMPLEXITY OF COMPLEXITY AND STRINGS WITH MAXIMAL PLAIN AND PREFIX KOLMOGOROV COMPLEXITY

Abstract

AbstractPéter Gács showed (Gács 1974) that for every n there exists a bit string x of length n whose plain complexity C(x) has almost maximal conditional complexity relative to x, i.e., $C\left( {C\left( x \right)|x} \right) \ge {\rm{log}}n - {\rm{log}}^{\left( 2 \right)} n - O\left( 1 \right)$ (Here ${\rm{log}}^{\left( 2 \right)} i = {\rm{loglog}}i$.) Following Elena Kalinina (Kalinina 2011), we provide a simple game-based proof of this result; modifying her argument, we get a better (and tight) bound ${\rm{log}}n - O\left( 1 \right)$ We also show the same bound for prefix-free complexity.Robert Solovay showed (Solovay 1975) that infinitely many strings x have maximal plain complexity but not maximal prefix complexity (among the strings of the same length): for some c there exist infinitely many x such that $|x| - C\left( x \right) \le c$ and $|x| + K\left( {|x|} \right) - K\left( x \right) \ge {\rm{log}}^{\left( 2 \right)} |x| - c{\rm{log}}^{\left( 3 \right)} |x|$ In fact, the results of Solovay and Gács are closely related. Using the result above, we provide a short proof for Solovay’s result. We also generalize it by showing that for some c and for all n there are strings x of length n with $n - C\left( x \right) \le c$ and $n + K\left( n \right) - K\left( x \right) \ge K\left( {K\left( n \right)|n} \right) - 3K\left( {K\left( {K\left( n \right)|n} \right)|n} \right) - c.$ We also prove a close upper bound $K\left( {K\left( n \right)|n} \right) + O\left( 1 \right)$Finally, we provide a direct game proof for Joseph Miller’s generalization (Miller 2006) of the same Solovay’s theorem: if a co-enumerable set (a set with c.e. complement) contains for every length a string of this length, then it contains infinitely many strings x such that$|x| + K\left( {|x|} \right) - K\left( x \right) \ge {\rm{log}}^{\left( 2 \right)} |x| - O\left( {{\rm{log}}^{\left( 3 \right)} |x|} \right).$