Discovering America: FromPaul BunyantoPeter Grimes

Abstract

AbstractBritten and Auden’s ‘choral operetta’Paul Bunyan, written in New York in 1939–41, has often been seen as out of touch with its American context and as an anomalous precursor to the triumphantPeter Grimes(1945). A closer look, however, suggests a more complex engagement with American musical life and with the problem of American operatic populism. Indeed, ifPaul Bunyanoffered one set of answers to this problem, toying with popular genres and smaller forms, the rejection of this approach inPeter Grimesalso seems tied to shifting American ideas about contemporary opera. Attention toPaul Bunyanin its American context highlights the transatlantic nature of both American and British operatic developments in the mid-twentieth century, while also recasting Britten’s operatic trajectory, restoring a sense of scepticism and uncertainty to his operatic project at its very beginnings.