Abstract
Rousseau claims that the lawgiver must “persuade without convincing,” binding this legislative communication to the “first language,” which would, Rousseau writes, “persuade without convincing, and depict without arguing.” Drawing on a wide range of contextual sources, I show that this first language of Rousseau's is figurative, imagistic, and modeled on ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs, which William Warburton claimed were “the uniform voice of nature” in his Divine Legation of Moses. More importantly, I demonstrate that Rousseau was himself using this lost ancient language to provide a figuration of his own: the “illusory image” of natural man. Through the Second Discourse, men could be persuaded that they were by nature free, preparing the way for a social contract in which they could legitimately give themselves law. This is an image that I argue has been effectively persuasive up to the present day—and our politics, like Rousseau's, thus seemingly rests on figurative foundations.
Publisher
Cambridge University Press (CUP)
Subject
Sociology and Political Science,Philosophy,History,Cultural Studies
Reference10 articles.
1. European Conceptions of ‘Exotic’ Writing Systems in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries;Neis;Language and History,2018
2. How to Do Things with Signs: Rousseau's Ancient Performative Idiom;Lifschitz;History of Political Thought,2016
3. Warburton and Some Aspects of the Search for the Primitive in Eighteenth-Century France;Cherpack;Philological Quarterly,1957
4. Homo Duplex: the two origins of man in Rousseau’s Second Discourse
5. "To Persuade without Convincing": The Language of Rousseau's Legislator