Correlation coefficient calculations for MIMO antenna systems: a comparative study

Abstract

The correlation coefficient (ρ) is an important metric for the evaluation of multiple-input–multiple-output (MIMO) antenna systems because it describes the relationship between the channels in a particular propagation environment. Highly correlated channels will degrade the MIMO system performance. Various methods to calculateρare analyzed in this work using three different types of antennas with different efficiencies and radiating properties. While the field-based method for findingρgives the most accurate results and should be used all the time. It is independent of antenna efficiency. The the S-parameter-based method might give reasonable results only when the antenna efficiency is very high and the patterns are separated in space, but in most cases, it underestimatesρvalues and thus is not a reliable method and should be avoided. Incorporating the antenna efficiency can improve theρestimates using the S-parameters method under some specific conditions. The equivalent circuit method provides reasonable results for symmetric antenna structures only, and is the most complex in formulation. As part of the evaluation, two existing methods incorporating the radiation efficiency of the antennas are generalized to N-ports for the first time. Although less accurate than the field-based method, these extensions allow the evaluation ofρfor N-port antennas using only the radiation efficiency and the S-parameters of the antenna. The effect of the beam tilts onρestimation is investigated for the first time.