Comparison of Retrograde Femoral Interlocking Nail Versus Dynamic Condylar Screw in Distal Femoral Shaft Fractures

Abstract

Objective: The aim of this study is to compare the effectiveness of retrograde femoral interlocking nail versus dynamic condylar screw in distal femoral shaft fractures. Study Design: Prospective/Randomized comprehensive Place and Duration: Department of Orthopaedic Surgery Bahawal Victoria Hospital (BVH) / QAMC, Bahawalpur for duration of eight months i.e July 2020 to February 2021. Methods: Total 65 patients of both genders were presented in this study with age ranges between 20-40 years. Patients detailed demographics age, sex and BMI were calculated after taking informed written consent. Patients were divided into 2- groups, I and II Group I had 32 patients and underwent for retrograde femoral interlocking nail and group II had 33 patients and received dynamic condylar screw. Mean operative time, mean union time of bones and complications were calculated. Effectiveness among both groups was calculated by HSS score. Complete data was analyzed by SPSS 22.0 version. Results: Most of the patients were males 40 (61.54%) and 25 (38.46%) were females. Mean age of the patients in group I was 26.46±4.28 years and in group II mean age was 30.78±8.22 years. Mean operative time in group I was 82.8±7.14 minutes while in group II it was 90.6±8.19 minutes. Mean union time in group I was 22.7±2.5 weeks and in group II was 26.21±5.3 weeks. According to HSS score in group I 16 (50%) results were excellent, 11 (34.38%) was good, 3 (9.8%) showed moderate and 2 (6.25%) was poor, while in group II excellent results were 15 (45.45%), 10 (30.30%) was good, 5 (15.15%) showed moderate and 3 (9.09%) showed poor results. Complications were observed joint stiffness, delayed union, non union and varus deformity were significantly lower in group I as compared to group II. Conclusion: We concluded in this comparison of study that bothretrograde femoral interlocking nail and dynamic condylar screw was useful and effective methods for trauma in distal femoral shaft fractures. But less union time and good outcomes were observed in interlocking nail as compared to dynamic condylar screw. Keywords: Distal femoral shaft fractures, Trauma, Dynamic condylar, Interlocking nail