Effect of intramedullary nail stiffness on load-sharing in tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis: A patient-specific finite element study

Abstract

Tibiotalocalcaneal (TTC) arthrodesis is a procedure to treat severe ankle and subtalar arthropathy by providing pain free and stable fusion using IM nails. These nails can be manufactured with multiple materials and some feature the ability to dynamize the arthrodesis construct. However, the impact of IM nail material and nail dynamization on load-sharing and in the setting of bone resorption have not been quantified. This work utilized a patient-specific finite element analysis model of TTC arthrodesis to investigate IM nails with differing material moduli and the impact of nail dynamization on load-sharing and intersegmental compression in the setting of bone resorption. Each nail was virtually inserted into a patient-specific model of a hindfoot, which was segmented into the three bones of the TTC complex and assigned material properties based on the densitometry of the bone. Compression, amount of load-sharing, and stress distributions after simulated bone resorption were quantified and compared between the varying IM nails. Simulations revealed that bone segments were only subjected to 17% and 22% of dynamic gait forces in the titanium and carbon fiber nail constructs, whereas the pseudoelastic NiTi nail constructs allowed for 67% of the same. The titanium and carbon fiber nails lost all initial compression in less than 0.13mm of bone resorption, whereas the NiTi nail maintained compression through all simulated values of bone resorption. These data highlight the poor load-sharing of static nail TTC arthrodesis constructs and the ability of a pseudoelastic IM nail construct to maintain intersegmental compression when challenged with bone resorption.