Affiliation:
1. Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich
Abstract
Abstract
In Plato's Cratylus, Hermogenes contends that the correctness of names is conventional. Appealing though this claim sounds to modern ears, it does not meet with approval in the Cratylus. Why? I argue that the conventionalism promoted by Hermogenes is discredited by unacceptable relativist implications because it incorporates the mistaken assumption that correct names are individuated exclusively by their phonetic composition.
Publisher
University of Illinois Press
Reference24 articles.
1. Language and Reality in Plato's Cratylus;Ackrill,1994
2. Plato's Cratylus: The Two Theories of the Correctness of Names;Anagnostopoulos;Review of Metaphysics,1972
3. Plato on Conventionalism;Barney;Phronesis,1997
4. Names and Nature in Plato's Cratylus