Affiliation:
1. Department of English, Research Center for Social Sciences and Education , University of Santo Tomas , Manila , The Philippines
2. Supreme Court of the Philippines , Branch 32, Metropolitan Trial Court – Quezon City , The Philippines
Abstract
AbstractThis paper analyzes the ambiguities in a Republic Act (RA) promulgated in the Philippines as its way of contributing to the gradually growing number of forensic and legal linguistics research in the country. In particular, it aims to disambiguate the different categories of ambiguities, e.g., lexical, semantic, syntactic, referential, cross-textual and pragmatic, in Republic Act 10913 or the Anti-Distracted Driving Act enacted in 2016. Following a purely qualitative design and a predominantly theoretical approach in the analysis of the ambiguities in the said Republic Act, this paper hopes to offer a potential source of guidance to minimize difficult issues pertinent to the interpretation of the law. This paper also attempts to discuss the basic rationale behind the choice or presence of ambiguous language in a setting such as the drafting of RA 10913 and proposes that there be a ‘cross-fertilization’ between the readings of legal drafters and linguists.
Subject
Law,Linguistics and Language
Reference55 articles.
1. Aalto-Heinila, Maija. 2016. Fairness in statutory interpretation: Text, purpose or intention? International Journal of Legal Discourse 1(1). 193–211. https://doi.org/10.1515/ijld-2016-0004.
2. Abiola, Kalejaiye, Barrister Buduka Isaac Otagiri & Idowu A. Olubunmi. 2019. Ambiguities in the language of law. A case study of selected court cases in Nigeria. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention 8(9). 53–59.
3. Adams, Kenneth A. & Allan S. Kaye. 2007. Revisiting the ambiguity of “and” and “or” in legal drafting. St. John’s Law Review 80(4). 1167–1198.
4. Agabin, Pacifico. 2018. Taking text and structure seriously: Two approaches to constitutional interpretation. [Paper Presentation]. Tagaytay City: PHILJA Training Center.
5. Allen, Layman. 1957. Symbolic logic: A razor-edged tool for drafting and interpreting legal documents. Yale Law Journal 66(6). 833–879.