Affiliation:
1. Leiden University Institute for Philosophy Nonnensteeg 1–3 Leiden Niederlande
Abstract
Abstract
With his doctrine of the “complete irresponsibility of man,” Nietzsche in different ways complicates the opposition between responsibility and irresponsibility. This article traces the different and conflicting senses of irresponsibility throughout Nietzsche’s development. First, the doctrine is shown to build on Nietzsche’s early study of Heraclitus (section I), whom Nietzsche admired for expounding and embodying a radical “innocence” that was both responsible and irresponsible in different senses. When presented as “philosophical conviction” in Human, All too Human, Nietzsche paradoxically speculates about the doctrine’s incorporation out of a sense of responsibility for the future of mankind (section II). Section III shows how Nietzsche’s later writings evince an increasing awareness of this paradox by explicitly positing complete irresponsibility as his own redemptive doctrine in Twilight of the Idols. After 1881, he has come to affirm a new notion of responsibility and criticizes a weak sense of irresponsibility as the abdication of one’s task. I end by discussing the relation of these different senses of irresponsibility, and argue that the fact that Nietzsche’s texts often deliberately complicate rather than clarify such distinctions is an important reflection of how he textually takes responsibility for “complete irresponsibility” (section IV).
Reference31 articles.
1. Arendt, Hannah: Responsibility and Judgment, ed. Jerome Kohn, New York 2003
2. Berry, Jessica: “Nietzsche and the Greeks,” in John Richardson / Ken Gemes (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Nietzsche, Oxford 2013, 83–107
3. Bishop, Paul: “Transforming Ourselves from a Moral into a Wise Humankind,” in Eike Brock / Jutta Georg (eds.), Friedrich Nietzsche: Menschliches, Allzumenschliches, Berlin 2020, 45–64
4. Blanchot, Maurice: The Infinite Conversation, trans. Susan Hanson, Minneapolis, MN 1993
5. Conway, Daniel: Nietzsche’s Dangerous Game: Philosophy in the “Twilight of the Idols”, Cambridge 1997