Author:
Prieger James E.,Kulick Jonathan
Abstract
Abstract
The textbook competitive model of drug markets predicts that greater law enforcement leads to higher black market prices, but also to the unintended consequences of greater revenue and violence. These predictions are not in accord with the paradoxical outcomes evinced by recent history in some drug markets, where enforcement rose even as prices fell. We show that predictions of the textbook model are not unequivocal, and that when bandwagon effects among scofflaws are introduced, the simple predictions are more likely to be reversed. We next show that even simple models of noncompetitive black markets can elicit paradoxical outcomes. Therefore, we argue that instead of searching for assumptions that lead to paradoxical outcomes, which is the direction the literature has taken, it is better for policy analysis to choose appropriate assumptions for the textbook model. We finish with performing such an analysis for the case of banning menthol cigarettes. Under the most plausible assumptions enforcement will indeed spur violence, although the legal availability of electronic cigarettes may mitigate or reverse this conclusion.
Subject
Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous),Economics and Econometrics
Reference124 articles.
1. Compass Estimating Consequences of a Ban on the Legal Sale of Menthol Cigarettes Accessed http www fda gov downloads AdvisoryCommittees CommitteesMeetingMaterials TobaccoProductsScientificAdvisoryCommittee pdf;Lexecon,2011
2. Marina Overview Tobacco Is the Most Widely Smuggled Legal Substance It Trafficking Fuels Organized Crime and Corruption Entry dated Accessed http www publicintegrity org overview;Guevara;October,2008
3. Peer Effects in Drug Use and Sex among College Students;Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,2005
4. Lessons from the Absence of Harm Reduction in American Drug Policy;Tobacco Control,1995
5. Cigarette Bans to Hit Europe The;Dalton;Journal,2013
Cited by
6 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献