1. Casey Ryan Kelly, Program in Media, Rhetoric, and Culture, Butler University ; Kristen E. Hoerl, Program in Media, Rhetoric, and Culture, Butler University . Previous versions of this essay were presented at the 2011 NCA/AFA Alta Conference on Argumentation, Alta, UT and the 2010 Central States Communication Association Conference, Cincinnati, OH. The authors wish to thank the Butler University Gender, Women, and Sexuality Studies program for financial support and Joan Faber McAlister for her...