Designing Weights for Quartet-Based Methods When Data are Heterogeneous Across Lineages

Abstract

AbstractHomogeneity across lineages is a general assumption in phylogenetics according to which nucleotide substitution rates are common to all lineages. Many phylogenetic methods relax this hypothesis but keep a simple enough model to make the process of sequence evolution more tractable. On the other hand, dealing successfully with the general case (heterogeneity of rates across lineages) is one of the key features of phylogenetic reconstruction methods based on algebraic tools. The goal of this paper is twofold. First, we present a new weighting system for quartets () based on algebraic and semi-algebraic tools, thus especially indicated to deal with data evolving under heterogeneous rates. This method combines the weights of two previous methods by means of a test based on the positivity of the branch lengths estimated with the paralinear distance. is statistically consistent when applied to data generated under the general Markov model, considers rate and base composition heterogeneity among lineages and does not assume stationarity nor time-reversibility. Second, we test and compare the performance of several quartet-based methods for phylogenetic tree reconstruction (namely QFM, wQFM, quartet puzzling, weight optimization and Willson’s method) in combination with several systems of weights, including weights and other weights based on algebraic and semi-algebraic methods or on the paralinear distance. These tests are applied to both simulated and real data and support weight optimization with weights as a reliable and successful reconstruction method that improves upon the accuracy of global methods (such as neighbor-joining or maximum likelihood) in the presence of long branches or on mixtures of distributions on trees.