On Huang and Wong’s algorithm for generalized binary split trees

Abstract

AbstractHuang and Wong (Acta Inform 21(1):113–123, 1984) proposed a polynomial-time dynamic-programming algorithm for computing optimal generalized binary split trees. We show that their algorithm is incorrect. Thus, it remains open whether such trees can be computed in polynomial time. Spuler (Optimal search trees using two-way key comparisons, PhD thesis, 1994) proposed modifying Huang and Wong’s algorithm to obtain an algorithm for a different problem: computing optimal two-way comparison search trees. We show that the dynamic program underlying Spuler’s algorithm is not valid, in that it does not satisfy the necessary optimal-substructure property and its proposed recurrence relation is incorrect. It remains unknown whether the algorithm is guaranteed to compute a correct overall solution.