Abstract
AbstractLewis’s original Best Systems Account of laws was not motivated much by pragmatics. But recent commentary on his general approach to laws has taken a ‘pragmatic turn’. This was initiated by Hall’s defence against the charge of ‘ratbag idealism’ which maintained that best systems accounts should be admired rather than criticised for the inherent pragmatism behind their choice of desiderata for what counts as ‘best’. Emboldened by Hall’s pragmatic turn, recent commentators have proposed the addition of pragmatically motivated desiderata to complement or replace the canonical desiderata of strength and simplicity. This, they hope, will allow their revisionary BSAs to respond better to various counterexamples against the original account. While the pragmatic turn itself is well taken, here I problematise these revisionary approaches. First, there are reasonable responses to the counterexamples from within the canonical BSA. Second, while actual laws may satisfy the newly proposed desiderata, there are reasons to think these desiderata cannot be constitutive of laws. By comparison, the canonical desiderata appear to be relevant to explaining why and when the revisionary desiderata will reflect pragmatic features of the laws and better reflect the motives behind practitioners of fundamental physics.
Funder
Horizon 2020 Framework Programme
Publisher
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Subject
History and Philosophy of Science,Philosophy
Reference39 articles.
1. Albert, D. (2015). After physics. Harvard University Press.
2. Ayer, A.J. (1999 [1956]). What is a law of nature? In: M. Tooley (Ed.), Laws of nature, causation, and supervenience (pp. 1–52). Garland Publishing
3. Beebee, H. (2000). The non-governing conception of laws of nature. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 61, 571–594.
4. Braddon-Mitchell, D. (2001). Lossy laws. Noûs, 35(2), 260–277.
5. Cohen, J., & Callender, C. (2009). A better best systems account of lawhood. Philosophical Studies, 145, 1–34.
Cited by
4 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献
1. Does the Best System Need the Past Hypothesis?;Philosophy of Science;2023-10-23
2. Every view is a view from somewhere: Pragmatist laws and possibility;THEORIA. An International Journal for Theory, History and Foundations of Science;2023-09-22
3. On Powers BSAs;The Philosophical Quarterly;2022-09-15
4. How to Be Humean about Idealization Laws;Philosophy of Science;2022-03-04