Author:
Motorniak David,Savulescu Julian,Giubilini Alberto
Abstract
AbstractDuring the COVID-19 pandemic, focused protection strategies including selective lockdowns of the elderly were proposed as alternatives to general lockdowns. These selective restrictions would consist of isolating only those most at risk of COVID-19 hospitalization and subsequent use of healthcare resources. The proposal seems to have troubling implications, including the permissibility of selective lockdown on the basis of characteristics such as ethnicity, sex, disability, or BMI. Like age, these factors also correlated with an increased risk of hospitalization from COVID-19. In this paper, we argue that age has meaningful differences as a morally relevant characteristic in the justification for selective restrictions of liberty. Thus, it might justify selective freedom restrictions in a way in which other factors might not. We offer four moral domains that separate age from other proxies: empiricism, operationality, discrimination, and disparity.
Publisher
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Subject
Health Policy,Health (social science)
Reference36 articles.
1. Australian Human Rights Commission. 2020. Ageism and COVID-19 [Internet]. Canberra, Australia. https://humanrights.gov.au/about/news/ageism-and-covid-19. Accessed October 4, 2021.
2. Banks, J., H. Karjalainen, and C. Propper. 2020. Recessions and health: The long-term health consequences of responses to the coronavirus. Fiscal Studies 41(2): 337–344.
3. Bhavsar, V., K. Kirkpatrick, M. Calcia, and L.M. Howard. 2021. Lockdown, domestic abuse perpetration, and mental health care: Gaps in training, research, and policy. Lancet Psychiatry 8(3):172–174.
4. Blunkett, D. 2020. It’s divisive and wrong—Please don’t stigmatise my generation: Former Home Secretary DAVID BLUNKETT, 72, says ordering the elderly to quarantine themselves is unfair [Internet]. The Daily Mail, March 16. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-8115207/FormerHome-Secretary-DAVID-BLUNKETT-says-ordering-elderly-quarantine-unfair.html.
5. Cameron, J., B. Williams, R. Ragonnet, B. Marais, J. Trauer, and J. Savulescu. 2021. Ethics of selective restriction of liberty in a pandemic. Journal of Medical Ethics 47(8): 1–10.