Abstract
AbstractThis paper draws upon the history of scientific studies of inheritance in Mendel’s best-remembered model organism, the garden pea, as a source of two parables – one pessimistic, the other optimistic – on the challenges of data linkage in plants. The moral of the pessimistic parable, from the era of the biometrician-Mendelian controversy, is that the problem of theory-ladenness in data sets can be a major stumbling block to making new uses of old data. The moral of the optimistic parable, from the long-run history of studies at the John Innes Centre of aberrant or “rogue” pea varieties, is that an excellent guarantor of the continued value of old data sets is the availability of the relevant physical materials – in the first instance, the plant seeds.
Publisher
Springer International Publishing
Reference28 articles.
1. Anonymous. (2021). The mystery of the Rabbit-Eared Rogues. John Innes Centre. https://www.jic.ac.uk. Accessed 10 Nov 2021.
2. Bateson, W. (1902). Mendel’s principles of heredity: A defence. Cambridge University Press.
3. Bateson, W. (1904). Practical aspects of the new discoveries in heredity. Proceedings: International Conference on Plant Breeding and Hybridization. Memoirs of the Horticultural Society of New York, 1, 1–9.
4. Bateson, W., & Pellew, C. (1915). On the genetics of ‘rogues’ among culinary peas (Pisum sativum). Journal of Genetics, 5, 13–36. plus plates.
5. Berry, D. J. (Forthcoming). Scientific activism and IP: How UK-based agroecology and plant synthetic biologists have challenged the status quo. In Designing nature: Essays on intellectual property law. Oxford University Press.