Compressed development, decompression, and diverging convergence in South Korea: which varieties of capitalism in contemporary Korea?

Abstract

AbstractSouth Korea has achieved compressed growth and convergence of its income level to that of typical advanced economies. This paper adopts a narrow definition of compressed development as a form of late development that lacks political democracy and open markets, and then defines decompression as the process of democratization and economic liberalization. This paper applies this framework of “compressed development, decompression, and diverging convergence” to analyze the dynamics of Korean capitalism since the 1980s after the death of the modernizer-dictator, President Park. First, the middle class emerged in Korea in the 1980s as a result of compressed growth since the 1960s and served as a key intermediary in linking economic growth to democratization. The process of political decompression, or democratization, was peaceful because it was demanded and led not by the working class but by the middle class. Second, an ill-managed first wave of economic decompression (liberalization) led to a financial crisis, and then, the post-crisis reforms (the second, more radical decompression) imposed by the IMF planted the institutional seeds for convergence with Anglo-American capitalism. Third, Korea is experiencing the end of the East Asian miracle, as evidenced by slowing growth and rising inequality, and is undergoing a multifaceted convergence toward different varieties of capitalism. In terms of life expectancy and crime rates, Korea joins Japan, Italy, and Spain in the “safe capitalism” group, while it is an extreme outlier in terms of its large gender wage gap and long working hours. In terms of unemployment and long-term employment rates, Korea is closer to the Anglo-American model, but closer to Europe in terms of the degree of active (or passive) labor market policies and legal protection against layoffs. Korea seems to be realizing “divergent convergence” as it remains distinct from any particular form of Western capitalism.