Efficiency of endovenous laser and glue ablation methods in comparison with conventional surgery for the treatment of venous ulcers

Abstract

Introduction In this study, we aimed to investigate the efficiency of endovenous laser and glue ablation techniques and compared the results with conventional surgical stripping. Patients and Methods Between January 2005 and January 2020, among 3133 consecutive patients with superficial venous reflux disease receiving treatment at our institution, there were 112 consecutive patients with active venous ulcers. Patients were divided into 3 groups as receiving conventional open surgical treatment (Group 1, n: 70), endovenous glue ablation (Group 2, n: 20), and endovenous laser ablation (Group 3, n: 22). Comorbidity factors, duration and size of the ulcers, deep, perforating, and small saphenous vein disease detected with detailed Doppler ultrasonography, and duration for healing and recurrence were investigated. Results The age, gender, comorbidities, smoking, history of previous treatment, diameter of the small saphenous vein, number of refluxing perforating veins, size of the ulcer, and ulcer recurrence ratio were not significantly different between groups. There were 7 patients with bilateral disease and in total 119 legs were intervened. Mean durations for complete ulcer healing were significantly lower in Group 1 (53.28 ± 22.1 days) than Group 2 (73.7 ± 39.6 days); however, it did not differ significantly between Group 1 and Group 3 (62.59 ± 19.65 days), and Group 2 and Group 3 ( p: 0.26). Ulcers recurred in 23 patients (33%) in stripping group at a mean follow up of 14.42 ± 4.6 months, in 7 patients (35%) in glue ablation group at a mean follow up of 11.97 ± 2.94 months, and in 5 patients (23%) in laser ablation group at a mean follow up of 12.66 ± 3.48 months ( p > 0.05 for all). Increased body mass index, co-existence of chronic venous insufficiency, active cigarette smoking, non-compliance with physician advises and exercise and compression stockings, and depth of the ulcers were correlated with recurrence. Conclusion The rationelle beyond treatment of the venous ulcers and prevention of recurrence relies on relief of the venous hypertension by interventional methods and/or compression therapy. None of the methods is superior over the others. Healing in short term without further recurrence may be achieved with successful intervention as well as good patient compliance.