Palpation Versus Ultrasonography for Identifying the Cricothyroid Membrane in Case of a Laterally Deviated Larynx: A Randomized Trial

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Large neck circumference and displacement of the trachea due to pathology increase the risk of failed identification of the cricothyroid membrane and cricothyroidotomy. We investigated whether ultrasound aids in the successful identification of the cricothyroid membrane in a model of an obese neck with midline deviation of the trachea. METHODS: We developed silicone neck models that were suitable for both palpation and ultrasonography and where the trachea deviated laterally from the midline to either side. After reading a book chapter and participating in a 25-minute lecture and a 15- to 23-minute hands-on demonstration and rehearsal of ultrasonography for identification of the cricothyroid membrane, anesthesiologists and anesthesiology residents randomly performed identification with either ultrasound or palpation on 1 of 2 neck models. RESULTS: We included 57 participants, of whom 29 and 28 were randomized to palpation and ultrasound, respectively. Correct identification of the cricothyroid membrane was achieved by 21 (75.0%) vs 1 (3.5%) of participants in the ultrasound versus palpation groups (risk ratio [RR], 21.8 [95% confidence interval {CI}, 3.1–151.0]). The tracheal midline position in the sagittal plane was identified correctly by 24 (85.7%) vs 16 (55.2%) of participants in the ultrasound versus palpation groups (RR, 1.6 [95% CI, 1.1–2.2]). CONCLUSIONS: Identification of the cricothyroid membrane in a model of an obese neck with midline deviation of the trachea was more often successful with ultrasound compared to palpation. Our study supports the potential use of ultrasound before induction of anesthesia and airway management in this group of patients, and it may even be applied in emergency situations when ultrasound is readily available. Further studies in human subjects should be conducted.