Head-to-head comparison of CCN4, DNMT3A, PTPN11, and SPARC as suppressors of anti-tumor immunity

Abstract

BackgroundEffective communication between innate and adaptive immunity is essential for mounting an effective antitumor immune response. Emergent cancer cells likely secrete factors that inhibit this communication. To identify such factors, we applied an in vitro workflow that coupled a functional assay with proteomics to a syngeneic mouse model of melanoma known to be resistant to immunotherapies. Collectively, these in vitro results suggested CCN4, DNMT3A, PTPN11, and SPARC as secreted factors that potentially mediate immunosuppression and could potentially become easily accessible targets for novel immunotherapies. The objective of this study was to test for consistent clinical correlates in existing human data and to verify in vivo whether knocking out tumor cell production of these secreted factors improved immune-mediated control of tumor growth.ResultsAnalyses of available human data indicate that high CCN4 expression is associated with reduced survival in primary melanoma patients. High DNMT3A, PTPN11, and SPARC expression showed no association with overall survival. In addition, scRNAseq data from patients with melanoma confirmed CCN4 is expressed by the tumor cells, as opposed to other cells in the tumor microenvironment. An experimental system was created using a CRISPR/Cas9 approach to generate knock out cell lines for each of the four genes of interest using the B16F0 mouse melanoma cell line. In a immunocompetent C57BL/6, DNMT3A, PTPN11, and SPARC knockouts had no effect on overall survival compared to mice challenged with wildtype B16F0 cells while the CCN4 knockout significantly increased survival. This increase in overall survival was lost when the CCN4 knockout cells were injected into severely immunocompromised NSG hosts, indicating that CCN4’s effect on the tumor microenvironment is immune mediated. A kinetic analysis leveraging a Markov Chain Monte Carlo approach quantified the various knockouts’ effect on cells’ intrinsic growth rate. The analysis shows CCN4 is the only knockout tested that decreased the net proliferation rate in immunocompetent mice compared to wildtype cells.ConclusionsThe results suggest that CCN4 is a mediator of immunosuppression in the melanoma tumor microenvironment and a potential collateral immunotherapy target.