Author:
Goletti Delia,Banaei Niaz,Batra Rahul,Berger Anne Emmanuelle,Blazevic Azra,Botelho-Nevers Elisabeth,Breen Ronan,Bruiners Natalie,Cambau Emmanuelle,Carbonnelle Etienne,Daley Charles L.,Descotes-Genon Cécile,Gennaro Francesco Di,Doucet-Populaire Florence,Esmail Aliasgar,Estrada Guzman Julia Dolores,Fontana Luc,Gennaro Maria Laura,Handler Deborah,Herrera Torres Rosa María,Hoft Daniel,Ismail Nahed,Isnard Margaux,Lardizabal Alfred,Lesage François Xavier,Lopes Amanda,López Vidal Williams Luciano,Contreras Rene Machado,Manivet Philippe,Marotte Hubert,Méchaï Frédéric,Medjahed-Artebasse Amel,Meldau Richard,Mérieux Yves,Morel Jacques,Mougari Faiza,Oelofse Suzette,Palmieri Fabrizio,Perrot Jean Luc,Petruccioli Elisa,Pride David T.,Tuaillon Edouard,Upton Caryn,Vanker Naadira,Dheda Keertan
Abstract
ABSTRACTBackgroundDetection and treatment of individuals with presumed latent tuberculosis (TB) infection (i.e., excluding active disease; LTBI) is imperative to achieve global TB control, as they represent a potential transmission reservoir. However, more sensitive and user-friendly diagnostic tools are needed.MethodsWe evaluated the accuracy for TB infection detection of the new VIDAS®TB-IGRA (bioMérieux), a fully automated, single tube (thus eliminating the need for batch testing) overnight incubation assay, compared to the QuantiFERON®-TB Gold Plus (QFT-Plus, QIAGEN), in a global multi-centre cross-sectional study (NCT04048018) that included patients with TB disease (n=200) or participants at varying levels of TB exposure (n=1460; mixed exposure-risk-population).ResultsVIDAS®TB-IGRA identified TB disease with greater sensitivity than QFT-Plus (97.5%vs. 80.7%,P<0.01%), and yielding significantly fewer false-negatives (2.5%vs. 17.5%;P<0.01%) and indeterminate results (1.0%vs. 9.5%;P=0.02%). In the mixed exposure-risk-population, negative (NPA) and positive percent agreement (PPA) were 90.1% (1097/1217) and 92.1% (223/242), respectively. PPA increased with TB-exposure risk (up to 95.7% for high-risk participants), whereas NPA decreased (starting from 96.9% for low-risk participants). Regression analyses revealed that VIDAS®TB-IGRA had a better fit with the risk-exposure gradient than the QFT-Plus. Specificity in extremely low TB-exposure risk participants (n= 125) was high for both VIDAS®TB-IGRA and QFT-Plus (97.6%vs. 95.2%;P=8.33%).ConclusionsVIDAS®TB-IGRA displayed greater sensitivity than QFT-Plus, had a lower indeterminate rate, correlated better with an exposure gradient, and was highly specific, suggesting that it is a potentially valuable tool for the diagnosis of LTBI.Take-home messageThe first fully automated interferon-γ-release assay—the bioMérieux VIDAS®TB-IGRA—is highly specific and displays greater sensitivity than QuantiFERON®-TB Gold Plus, and thus represents a valuable new and streamlined diagnostic tool for TB infection.
Publisher
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Reference41 articles.
1. Global tuberculosis report 2023. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2023. Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO.
2. Centers For Disease Control and Prevention. Tuberculosis Fact Sheets [Internet]. The Difference Between Latent TB Infection and TB Disease; 2019.Available from: https://www.cdc.gov/tb/publications/factsheets/general/ltbiandactivetb.htm.
3. Evaluation of a model for efficient screening of tuberculosis contact subjects;Am J Respir Crit Care Med United States,2008
4. Acuña-Villaorduña C , Jones-López EC , Fregona G , Marques-Rodrigues P , Gaeddert M , Geadas C , Hadad DJ , White LF , Molina LPD , Vinhas S , Ribeiro-Rodrigues R , Salgame P , Palaci M , Alland D , Ellner JJ , Dietze R. Intensity of exposure to pulmonary tuberculosis determines risk of tuberculosis infection and disease. European Respiratory Journal [Internet] European Respiratory Society; 2018 [cited 2022 Apr 11]; 51Available from: https://erj.ersjournals.com/content/51/1/1701578.
5. The spectrum of latent tuberculosis: rethinking the biology and intervention strategies