3D ultrasound-augmented image guidance for surgery of high-grade gliomas – A quantitative analysis focused on the extent of resection

Abstract

Background: We have retrospectively reviewed our series of brain tumor patients operated on using 3D IntraOperative UltraSound (IOUS) to report technical advantages and areas of improvement. Methods: Clinical and radiological data of patients with a diagnosis of high-grade glioma IV operated with and without IOUS were retrieved and analyzed. Results: We have found 391 patients operated using IOUS coupled with neuronavigation and 257 using neuronavigation standalone. We have selected a pool of 60 patients with a diagnosis of GlioBlastoma (GB), comparing two equally sized groups operated with and without IOUS, respectively. The average extent of resection (EOR) in the IOUS group was 93%, while in the control group, it was 80%. IOUS was significantly associated with improved EOR (P < 0.0004), even when accounting for other factors affecting EOR. The average overall survival (OS) was 13.4 months, and the average progression-free survival (PFS) was 7.4 months. The Cox proportional hazard model showed an advantage in OS on patients operated using the IOUS. No statistically significant effect was observed on PFS. Conclusion: Intraoperative ultrasound coupled with image guidance is associated with an improved EOR and possibly an improved OS. While we are aware of several limitations related to the present analysis, these data support the routine use of IOUS as a safe and reliable technology. Larger, prospective series with updated IOUS technology are desirable to verify the accuracy of these results.