Decoherence ensures convergence of non-adiabatic molecular dynamics with number of states

Abstract

Non-adiabatic (NA) molecular dynamics (MD) is a powerful approach for studying far-from-equilibrium quantum dynamics in photophysical and photochemical systems. Most NA-MD methods are developed and tested with few-state models, and their validity with complex systems involving many states is not well studied. By modeling intraband equilibration and interband recombination of charge carriers in MoS2, we investigate the convergence of three popular NA-MD algorithms, fewest switches surface hopping (FSSH), global flux surface hopping (GFSH), and decoherence induced surface hopping (DISH) with the number of states. Only the standard DISH algorithm converges with the number of states and produces Boltzmann equilibrium. Unitary propagation of the wave function in FSSH and GFSH violates the Boltzmann distribution, leads to internal inconsistency between time-dependent Schrödinger equation state populations and trajectory counts, and produces non-convergent results. Introducing decoherence in FSSH and GFSH by collapsing the wave function fixes these problems. The simplified version of DISH that omits projecting out the occupied state and is applicable to few-state systems also causes problems when the number of states is increased. We discuss the algorithmic application of wave function collapse and Boltzmann detailed balance and provide detailed FSSH, GFSH, and DISH flow charts. The use of convergent NA-MD methods is highly important for modeling complicated quantum processes involving multiple states. Our findings provide the basis for investigating quantum dynamics in realistic complex systems.