Operational complexities in international clinical trials: a systematic review of challenges and proposed solutions

Abstract

ObjectiveInternational trials can be challenging to operationalise due to incompatibilities between country-specific policies and infrastructures. The aim of this systematic review was to identify the operational complexities of conducting international trials and identify potential solutions for overcoming them.DesignSystematic review.Data sourcesMedline, Embase and Health Management Information Consortium were searched from 2006 to 30 January 2023.Eligibility criteriaAll studies reporting operational challenges (eg, site selection, trial management, intervention management, data management) of conducting international trials were included.Data extraction and synthesisSearch results were independently screened by at least two reviewers and data were extracted into a proforma.Results38 studies (35 RCTs, 2 reports and 1 qualitative study) fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The median sample size was 1202 (IQR 332–4056) and median number of sites was 40 (IQR 13–78). 88.6% of studies had an academic sponsor and 80% were funded through government sources. Operational complexities were particularly reported during trial set-up due to lack of harmonisation in regulatory approvals and in relation to sponsorship structure, with associated budgetary impacts. Additional challenges included site selection, staff training, lengthy contract negotiations, site monitoring, communication, trial oversight, recruitment, data management, drug procurement and distribution, pharmacy involvement and biospecimen processing and transport.ConclusionsInternational collaborative trials are valuable in cases where recruitment may be difficult, diversifying participation and applicability. However, multiple operational and regulatory challenges are encountered when implementing a trial in multiple countries. Careful planning and communication between trials units and investigators, with an emphasis on establishing adequately resourced cross-border sponsorship structures and regulatory approvals, may help to overcome these barriers and realise the benefits of the approach.Open science framework registration numberosf-registrations-yvtjb-v1.