Population Structure, Mating Type, and Mefenoxam Sensitivity of Phytophthora nicotianae in Virginia Tobacco Fields

Abstract

Black shank is an important disease of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) caused by the fungus-like organism, Phytophthora nicotianae. Three physiological races (0, 1, and 3) have been documented in the United States. Shifts in the pathogen population structure have become a concern due to the widespread use of cultivars possessing resistance to race 0 arising from a single gene (Php or Phl). A comprehensive statewide survey conducted throughout major tobacco-growing areas during summer 2006 and supplemented by additional isolates in 2007 and 2008 yielded 217 isolates from flue-cured, burley, and dark fire-cured tobacco fields. After determining species identity using a single-strand conformational polymorphism fingerprinting technique, the race identity of isolates was assessed via greenhouse tests using three differential cultivars (Hicks, L8, and NC1071). Approximately 76% of the isolates belonged to race 1, 21% to race 0, and the remaining 3% were race 3. This race structure was comparable with those in the other tobacco-producing states in the United States. Approximately 94% of isolates belonged to A2 mating type and merely 6% were A1. These data suggest that it is unlikely that sexual recombination serves as a major mechanism enhancing the genetic diversity of the pathogen in Virginia. All isolates were also evaluated against mefenoxam at 5 μg/ml. None were insensitive; 98% of isolates were either highly sensitive or sensitive and the remaining 2% were intermediately sensitive. These results indicate that mefenoxam remains effective for control of black shank in Virginia. The results of this study can assist breeders to develop cultivars possessing the most appropriate set of disease resistance traits, as well as extension specialists, county agents, and tobacco growers in their decision-making process to manage tobacco black shank in Virginia.