Spatial persistence of reduced specific ventilation following methacholine challenge in the healthy human lung

Abstract

Specific ventilation imaging was used to identify regions of the healthy lung (6 supine subjects, ages 21–41 yr, 3 men) that experienced a fall in specific ventilation following inhalation of methacholine. This test was repeated 1 wk later and 3 mo later to test for spatial recurrence. Our data showed that 53% confidence interval (CI; 46%, 59%) of volume elements that constricted during one methacholine challenge did so again in another and that this quantity did not vary with time; 46% CI (28%, 64%) recurred 1 wk later, and 56% CI (51%, 61%) recurred 3 mo later. Previous constriction was a strong predictor for future constriction. Volume elements that constricted during one challenge were 7.7 CI (5.2, 10.2) times more likely than nonconstricted elements to constrict in a second challenge, regardless of whether the second episode was 1 wk [7.7 CI (2.9, 12.4)] or 3 mo [7.7 CI (4.6, 10.8)] later. Furthermore, posterior lung elements were more likely to constrict following methacholine than anterior lung elements (volume fraction 0.43 ± 0.22 posterior vs. 0.10 ± 0.03 anterior; P = 0.005), and basal elements that constricted were more likely than their apical counterparts to do so persistently through all three trials (volume fraction 0.14 ± 0.04 basal vs. 0.04 ± 0.04 apical; P = 0.003). Taken together, this evidence suggests a physiological predisposition toward constriction in some lung elements, especially those located in the posterior and basal lung when the subject is supine. NEW & NOTEWORTHY The spatial pattern of bronchoconstriction following methacholine is persistent over time in healthy individuals, in whom chronic inflammation and airway remodeling are assumed to be absent. This suggests that regional lung inflation and airway structure may play dominant roles in determining the spatial pattern of methacholine bronchoconstriction.