Author:
Lewis Harry R.,Goldfarb Warren D.
Abstract
In this paper we consider classes of quantificational formulas specified by restrictions on the number of atomic subformulas appearing in a formula. Little seems to be known about the decision problem for such classes, except that the class whose members contain at most two distinct atomic subformulas is decidable [2]. (We use “decidable” and “undecidable” throughout with respect to satisfiability rather than validity. All undecidable problems to which we refer are of maximal r.e. degree.) The principal result of this paper is the undecidability of the class of those formulas containing five atomic subformulas and with prefixes of the form ∀∃∀…∀. In fact, we show the undecidability of two sub-classes of this class: one (Theorem 1) consists of formulas whose matrices are in disjunctive normal form with two disjuncts; the other (Corollary 1) consists of formulas whose matrices are in conjunctive normal form with three conjuncts. (Theorem 1 sharpens Orevkov's result [8] that the class of formulas in disjunctive normal form with two disjuncts is undecidable.) A second corollary of Theorem 1 shows the undecidability of the class of formulas with prefixes of the form ∀…∀∃, containing six atomic subformulas, and in conjunctive normal form with three conjuncts. These restrictions to prefixes ∀∃∀…∀ and ∀…∀∃ are optimal. For by a result of the first author [5], any class of prenex formulas obtained by restricting both the number of atomic formulas and the number of universal quantifiers is reducible to a finite class of formulas, and so each such class is decidable; and the class of formulas with prefixes ∃…∃∀…∀ is, of course, decidable.
Publisher
Cambridge University Press (CUP)
Reference8 articles.
1. An inverse method of establishing deducibilities in the classical predicate calculus;Maslov;Soviet Mathematics Doklady,1964
2. Dreben B. S. and Goldfarb W. D. , A systematic treatment of the decision problem (forthcoming).
3. Logical Writings
Cited by
11 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献
1. Thue trees;Annals of Pure and Applied Logic;2003-02
2. Complexity Results for First-Order Two-Variable Logic with Counting;SIAM Journal on Computing;2000-01
3. Smallest horn clause programs;The Journal of Logic Programming;1996-06
4. Termination of logic programs: the never-ending story;The Journal of Logic Programming;1994-05
5. One binary horn clause is enough;Lecture Notes in Computer Science;1994