The limits of autonomy in thyroid oncology

Abstract

Abstract:  It is widely believed that respecting patient autonomy obligates practitioners to accede to all patients’ preferences and requests regardless of potential consequences to their health or to the professional integrity of the practitioner. This is a false belief that misrepresents the basic theoretical concepts surrounding the principles of autonomy and respect for persons, which must be balanced with other core medical ethical principles. There are many situations in which there are limits to autonomy. This clinical ethics article, intended for clinicians, will discuss various conditions in which autonomy-limiting principles and concepts apply, which are specific to the thyroid oncology context. The ethical and legal obligations of thyroid oncologists in such situations will also be explored.