Temperature-dependent effects of neonicotinoids on the embryonic development of zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Abstract

The agricultural use of neonicotinoids is increasing worldwide and poses a threat to non-target organisms. The existing toxicity data of neonicotinoids that is mainly focused on widely used neonicotinoids ignores the influence of environmental factors, like temperature, related to climate changes, etc. To fill this data gap, the present study assessed the temperature-dependent toxicity of six neonicotinoids at four temperatures. Briefly, a fish embryo toxicity test was performed at the following temperatures—20, 23, 28, and 33°C—on zebrafish embryos to evaluate the lethal and sublethal effects of these toxicants. At 28°C, the lethal toxicity (LC50) values for these toxicants were cycloxaprid—3.36 mg/L, nitenpyram—7.08 mg/L, paichongding—17.2 mg/L, imidaclothiz—738.6 mg/L, dinotefuran—2,096 mg/L, and thiamethoxam—4,293 mg/L, respectively. Among the sublethal effects, the enzymatic activities changed significantly in neonicotinoid treatments, which revealed oxidative stress, metabolic disorders, and neurotoxicity. Particularly, acetylcholinesterase inhibition and glutathione S-transferase activation showed a significant dose–response relationship. However, cycloxaprid, nitenpyram, and paichongding were found to be more potent compared with imidaclothiz and thiamethoxam. The influence of temperature on these neonicotinoids demonstrated an inverted V-shaped relationship, in which toxicity decreased with the increase of temperature and then increased with the increase of temperature after exceeding the optimum temperature. This study provides a reference for the multiscale effects and potential mechanisms of neonicotinoids. Temperature-dependent toxicity is of great significance for future toxicity testing and risk assessment of chemicals in the face of global climate changes.