Meta-analysis of set-based multiple phenotype association test based on GWAS summary statistics from different cohorts

Abstract

Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have emerged as popular tools for identifying genetic variants that are associated with complex diseases. Standard analysis of a GWAS involves assessing the association between each variant and a disease. However, this approach suffers from limited reproducibility and difficulties in detecting multi-variant and pleiotropic effects. Although joint analysis of multiple phenotypes for GWAS can identify and interpret pleiotropic loci which are essential to understand pleiotropy in diseases and complex traits, most of the multiple phenotype association tests are designed for a single variant, resulting in much lower power, especially when their effect sizes are small and only their cumulative effect is associated with multiple phenotypes. To overcome these limitations, set-based multiple phenotype association tests have been developed to enhance statistical power and facilitate the identification and interpretation of pleiotropic regions. In this research, we propose a new method, named Meta-TOW-S, which conducts joint association tests between multiple phenotypes and a set of variants (such as variants in a gene) utilizing GWAS summary statistics from different cohorts. Our approach applies the set-based method that Tests for the effect of an Optimal Weighted combination of variants in a gene (TOW) and accounts for sample size differences across GWAS cohorts by employing the Cauchy combination method. Meta-TOW-S combines the advantages of set-based tests and multi-phenotype association tests, exhibiting computational efficiency and enabling analysis across multiple phenotypes while accommodating overlapping samples from different GWAS cohorts. To assess the performance of Meta-TOW-S, we develop a phenotype simulator package that encompasses a comprehensive simulation scheme capable of modeling multiple phenotypes and multiple variants, including noise structures and diverse correlation patterns among phenotypes. Simulation studies validate that Meta-TOW-S maintains a desirable Type I error rate. Further simulation under different scenarios shows that Meta-TOW-S can improve power compared with other existing meta-analysis methods. When applied to four psychiatric disorders summary data, Meta-TOW-S detects a greater number of significant genes.