Security Analysis of the MQTT-SN Protocol for the Internet of Things

Abstract

The expansion of the Internet of Things (IoT) paradigm has brought with it the challenge of promptly detecting and evaluating attacks against the systems coexisting in it. One of the most recurrent methods used by cybercriminals is to exploit the vulnerabilities found in communication protocols, which can lead to them accessing, altering, and making data inaccessible and even bringing down a device or whole infrastructure. In the case of the IoT, the Message Queuing Telemetry Transport (MQTT) protocol is one of the most-used ones due to its lightness, allowing resource-constrained devices to communicate with each other. Improving its effectiveness, a lighter version of this protocol, namely MQTT for Sensor Networks (MQTT-SN), was especially designed for embedded devices on non-TCP/IP networks. Taking into account the importance of these protocols, together with the significance that security has when it comes to protecting the high-sensitivity data exchanged in IoT networks, this paper presents an exhaustive assessment of the MQTT-SN protocol and describes its shortcomings. In order to do so, seven different highly heterogeneous attacks were designed and tested, evaluating the different security impacts that they can have on a real MQTT-SN network and its performance. Each one of them was compared with a non-attacked implemented reference scenario, which allowed the comparison of an attacked system with that of a system without attacks. Finally, using the knowledge extracted from this evaluation, a threat detector is proposed that can be deployed in an IoT environment and detect previously unmodeled attacks.