A Comparative Study on the Difference in Temperature and Salinity Tolerance of Crassostrea nippona and C. gigas Spat

Abstract

Although Crassostrea nippona and C. gigas are occasionally found to be sympatric, little is known about the differences in tolerance against environmental stresses between species, which may potentially result in severe economic losses due to the neglect of species-specific biological characteristics in farming practices. Therefore, two independent and consecutive experiments were performed to evaluate the differences in temperature and salinity tolerance between C. nippona and C. gigas spat and determine the optimal environmental conditions for the aquaculture of C. nippona spat. The experimental results of dynamic treatment showed that the accumulative survival rate (ASR) of C. nippona spat was generally lower than that of C. gigas throughout temperature changes and salinity decreases, while the ASR of C. nippona spat was superior to that of C. gigas with increasing salinity. In addition, the daily growth rate (DGR) of both species was significantly inhibited at 18 °C and peaked at 25 °C with increasing temperature (p < 0.05) at each experimental salinity. At 32 °C, the survival rate (SR) of C. nippona spat was significantly lower than that of C. gigas on day 10 at all salinities tested (p < 0.05), whereas the difference in the SR between species at 35 psu gradually disappeared with prolonged stress time. The data indicated that C. gigas spat was suitable for rearing at temperatures of 25 and 32 °C at all salinity levels, except the combination of 32 °C and 35 psu. By contrast, combinations of 25 °C and salinities of 21–35 psu were considered as the optimal environmental conditions for the long-term culture of C. nippona spat. These present findings contribute to a better understanding of the tolerance of C. nippona spat to environmental stresses and suggest that particular attention should be paid to the inferior adaptability of C. nippona when farming in locations outside their natural habitats.