Improved Deep Learning Predictions for Chlorophyll Fluorescence Based on Decomposition Algorithms: The Importance of Data Preprocessing

Abstract

Harmful algal blooms (HABs) have been deteriorating global water bodies, and the accurate prediction of algal dynamics using the modelling method is a challenging research area. High-frequency monitoring and deep learning technology have opened up new horizons for HAB forecasting. However, the non-stationary and stochastic process behind algal dynamics monitoring largely limits the prediction performance and the early warning of algal booms. Through an analysis of the published literature, we found that decomposition methods are widely used in time-series analysis for hydrological processes. Predictions of ecological indicators have received less attention due to their inherent fluctuations. This study explores and demonstrates the predictive enhancement for chlorophyll fluorescence data based on the coupling of three decomposition algorithms with conventional deep learning models: the convolutional neural network (CNN) and long short-term memory (LSTM). We found that the decomposition algorithms can successfully capture the time-series patterns of chlorophyll fluorescence concentrations. The results indicate that decomposition-based models can enhance the accuracy of single models in predicting chlorophyll concentrations in terms of the improvement percentages in RMSE (with increases ranging from 25.7% to 71.3%), MAE (ranging from 28.3% to 75.7%), and R2 values (increasing ranging from 14.8% to 34.8%). In addition, the comparison experiment for different decomposition methods might suggest the superiority of singular spectral analysis in hourly predictive tasks of chlorophyll fluorescence over the wavelet transform and empirical mode decomposition models. Overall, while decomposition methods come with their respective strengths and weaknesses, they are undeniably efficient in combination with deep learning models in dealing with the high-frequency monitoring of chlorophyll fluorescence data. We also suggest that model developers pay more attention to online data preprocessing and conduct comparative analyses to determine the best model combinations for forecasting algal blooms and water management.