Affiliation:
1. Civil and Environmental Engineering Graduate Program, College of Engineering, São Paulo State University, 14-01 Eng. Luiz E.C. Coube Avenue, Bauru 17033-360, Brazil
2. Environmental Engineering Department, Institute of Science and Technology, São Paulo State University, 500 Altino Bondensan Road, São José dos Campos 12245-000, Brazil
3. Natural Disasters Graduate Program, Brazilian Center for Early Warning and Monitoring for Natural Disasters, 500 Altino Bondensan Road, São José dos Campos 12245-000, Brazil
Abstract
Coagulation is the most sensitive step in drinking water treatment. Underdosing may not yield the required water quality, whereas overdosing may result in higher costs and excess sludge. Traditionally, the coagulant dosage is set based on bath experiments performed manually, known as jar tests. Therefore, this test does not allow real-time dosing control, and its accuracy is subject to operator experience. Alternatively, solutions based on machine learning (ML) have been evaluated as computer-aided alternatives. Despite these advances, there is open debate on the most suitable ML method applied to the coagulation process, capable of the most highly accurate prediction. This study addresses this gap, where a comparative analysis between ML methods was performed. As a research hypothesis, a data-driven (D2) fuzzy inference system (FIS) should provide the best performance due to its ability to deal with uncertainties inherent to complex processes. Although ML methods have been widely investigated, only a few studies report hybrid neuro-fuzzy systems applied to coagulation. Thus, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first study thus far to address the accuracy of this non-hybrid data-driven FIS (D2FIS) for such an application. The D2FIS provided the smallest error (0.69 mg/L), overcoming the adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (1.09), cascade-correlation network (1.18), gene expression programming (1.15), polynomial neural network (1.20), probabilistic network (1.17), random forest (1.26), radial basis function network (1.28), stochastic gradient tree boost (1.25), and support vector machine (1.17). This finding points to the D2FIS as a promising alternative tool for accurate real-time coagulant dosage in drinking water treatment. In conclusion, the D2FIS can help WTPs to reduce operating costs, prevent errors associated with manual processes and operator experience, and standardize the efficacy with real-time and highly accurate predictions, and enhance safety for the water industry. Moreover, the evidence from this study can assist in filling the gap with the most suitable ML method and identifying a promising alternative for computer-aided coagulant dosing. For further advances, future studies should address the potential of the D2FIS for the control and optimization of other unit operations in drinking water treatment.
Funder
São Paulo Research Foundation
Subject
Water Science and Technology,Aquatic Science,Geography, Planning and Development,Biochemistry
Reference53 articles.
1. Multimodal control by variable-structure neural network modeling for coagulant dosing in water purification process;Zhang;Complexity,2020
2. A real-time optimization control method for coagulation process during drinking water treatment;Wang;Nonlinear Dyn.,2021
3. Application of uncertainty analysis of artificial neural networks for predicting coagulant and alkalizer dosages in a water treatment process;Menezes;Br. J. Chem. Eng.,2018
4. Development and comparison of extreme learning machine and multi-layer perceptron neural network models for predicting optimum coagulant dosage for water treatment;Jayaweera;J. Phys.,2018
5. Prediction of the optimal dosage of coagulants in water treatment plants through developing models based on artificial neural network fuzzy inference system (ANFIS);Narges;J. Environ. Health Sci. Eng.,2021