Using seasonal oscillations in fin ray microchemistry to chemically age Lake Sturgeon

Abstract

AbstractObjectiveNonlethally sampled pectoral fin rays are commonly used as aging structures for Lake Sturgeon Acipenser fulvescens, but they tend to underestimate the true age in older, slow‐growing individuals (age > 14 years). Current aging practices involve counting bands along the structure, which are construed as annuli. Oscillations of certain trace elements corresponding with annuli have been seen across various fish species, with patterns continuing to the marginal edge of hard structures. This study explored the aging of fin rays by using microchemistry patterns in Lake Sturgeon of known age (n = 94; ages 5–21) to determine the potential use of this method as an alternative or supplementary aging technique.MethodsElements were chosen for age determination analysis by examining the relationship between profile minima/maxima and visually interpreted annuli. Fish were assigned ages using three different methods: (1) traditional interpretation (counting annuli along the structure), (2) chemical interpretation (examination of seasonal variations in elemental profiles with visually identified annuli), and (3) a statistical model (multivariate multiple changepoint analysis with finite differencing using raw elemental profiles).ResultMean absolute differences between age estimates and known age were significantly higher for the traditional interpretation method than for the chemical interpretation method. The mean coefficient of variation in estimated age was 11.14% for the traditional interpretation method and 4.04% for the chemical interpretation method. The changepoint model was able to correctly classify age for 100% of the samples within ±1 year in one population (ages 5–8) but could not classify samples from the second population (ages 12–21).ConclusionOur results suggest that chemical aging techniques could provide more reliable age estimates for juvenile and subadult Lake Sturgeon when fin rays are the only aging option. Further work is required to determine the applicability of the model for assigning ages to older fish and for use with different populations and structures.