Dosimetric Comparison of Different Radionuclides Used in Metastatic Bone Disease Treatment

Abstract

Introduction: This study aimed to determine the critical organ doses in 223Ra, 89Sr, 153Sm, and 32P treatments via dosimetry using the phantoms. Material and Methods: The OpenDose was used to calculate S values (mGy MBq-1s-1) for bone surface, red bone marrow, urinary bladder wall, testes, ovaries, uterus, and kidneys using male (ICRP110AM) and female (ICRP110AF) phantoms. The cortical thoracic spine was modeled as me-tastasis. Moreover, the absorbed doses were computed via MIRD formalism according to the activi-ties of 3.3, 148, 2220, and 370 MBq for ICRP110AM and 4.015, 148, 2701, and 370 MBq for ICRP110AF in 223Ra, 89Sr, 153Sm, and 32P treatments, respectively. Results: Whilst the maximum bone surface doses were found as 1.22E+02 and 8.51E+01 mGy at 32P treatment, the minimum bone surface doses were calculated as 8.42E-02 and 8.26E-02 mGy at 223Ra. In terms of the comparison of red bone marrow, urinary bladder wall, and kidney doses, 153Sm and 89Sr treatments showed maximum doses of 2.45E-03, 1.50E-03, 3.23E-07, 5.45E-06, 1.20E-01, 1.49E-01 mGy and the minimum doses with 3.46E-05, 1.99E-05, 6.33E-09, 8.77E-09, 1.19E-04, 1.15E-04 mGy, respectively. The maximum testes and ovaries-uterus doses were found as 6.17E-08, 7.40E-06, 3.46E-07 mGy in 153Sm treatment, and minimum testes and ovaries doses as 1.70E-09, 1.34E-07 mGy in 223Ra. The minimum uterus dose with 7.03E-09 mGy was determined in 89Sr treat-ment. Conclusion: It is observed that 223Ra produces low critical organ doses in the treatment of painful bone metastasis. Among the beta-emitting radionuclides, 89Sr stands out by showing optimal dosi-metric results.